Clothing as a Reflection
of Economic Status, Familial Association, and Religious Affiliation in The
Book of Margery Kempe
(Rachel Arnold, Holy Cross
'99)
Social scientists have
attributed two major functions to clothing; to provide concealment in the
name of modesty and to protect the body against inclement weather. The significance
of clothing, however, goes behind mere protection. One of the first analyses
of clothing as a symbol of position within society was published by Thorstein
Veblen, in his Theory of the Leisure Class of 1899. In this work,
Veblen suggested that the wife’s clothing is the showcase through which the
husband displays his wealth. The higher the income, the more the husband
can indulge his wife in extravagant clothing. Many of the same principles
continue to permeate modern day society. The economic system of capitalism,
the principle upon which the United States, and Veblen's critique, is based,
asserts that each member of society has an opportunity to obtain financial
security. As such, the display of personal wealth is often correlated with
intelligence and dedication. During the time of Margery Kempe, medieval England
was in the initial stages of transition from land-bound wealth to a mercantile
and cash economy. Thus, the socioeconomic groups who were capable of lavish
displays of wealth were no longer exclusively nobles. The successful merchants
were eager to imitate the extravagant lifestyle and appearance of the traditional
aristocracy.
As an author, Margery Kempe exercised
her ability to write about clothing in order to substantiate the image she
wished to present. The references to specific types of dress in The Book
of Margery Kempe begin within the first chapter of the book. Margery
has a vision of the Lord sitting upon her bed "clad in mantle of purple silk."
Both the color and texture of the cloak seen in her vision are indicative
of royalty. In the Middle Ages, as well as modern day society, purple is
a color that is frequently associated with royalty. In Margery’s time, peasants
would be unable to afford either the brilliant dye or the silken material.
The most coveted fabrics of this time period were those which had made the
longest journey. Possession of Cyprus silks or Venetian velvets easily distinguished
the wealthy from the peasant. When Margery describes the appearance of the
man in her vision, whom she identifies as the Lord, the people of her time
would immediately identify him as a man elevated status.
Our first glimpse of Margery’s
appearance is revealed in the second chapter. Margery reflects on her proud
demeanor that was evidenced by her showy manner of dressing. She describes
the ornate costume in which she once promenaded through town, "she wore
gold pipes on her head, and her hoods with the tippets were fashionably
slashed. Her cloaks were also modishly slashed and underlaid with various
colors between the slashes."Clothing fitting this description, expensive
textiles of an underlayer exposed through slashes and gold wires set off
by streamers in a headdress, was at the height of fashion; sources indicate
that it was an imported luxury. Margery conveys her confidence and vigor
when she exclaims, "she knew full well that people made adverse comments
about her." It could be argued that she used her dress to assert her financial
superiority over her neighbors. "She was enormously envious of her neighbors
if they were dressed as well as she was. Her whole desire was to be respected
by people." It is likely, however, that Margery exaggerated her extravagance
in appearance in her earlier years in order to emphasize her subsequent conversion
from a prideful to pious woman.
Clothing was not only a means
of displaying wealth and status, it was also an effective means of exhibiting
religious devotion. In the third chapter, Margery introduces religious conversion
demonstrated through clothing. She describes wearing a hair shirt, an uncomfortable
scratchy garment that was a common symbol of public penance. Although Margery
wore the hair shirt under her clothes, not as an outward symbol to society,
her reference is a testimonial of her conversion. From the outset, then,
Margery introduces herself through her costume; the shift of dress within
the first three books describes her radically transformed outlook on life.
Her clothing, in addition to other symbolic events, is continually used throughout
the rest of her book as tangible evidence of her interior state. The most
important reference to clothing as a sign of her piety is her unflagging efforts
to wear white clothing.
The Significance of
White Clothing
In the time of Margery Kempe,
consecrated virgins were considered to be among the holiest of individuals.
The theory behind the practice was that by the renunciation of sexual expression
the virgin could devote her life and love entirely to God. Although Margery
is clearly not a virgin, she is the mother of fourteen children, we witness
her in Chapter 11 convincing her husband to renounce sexual expression and
allow her to live a chaste life. Margery wishes to demonstrate to society
that she is a woman of virtue, which she accomplishes by the wearing of all
white clothing. The use of white as a symbolic image is present throughout
The Book of Margery Kempe and serves a dual purpose. By
wearing all white, Margery is able to align herself with the holy women she
wishes to emulate, in addition to displaying her conversion to the world.
In Chapter 15, Margery has a
vision in which the Lord proclaims to her, "And, daughter, I say to you that
I want you to wear all white clothes and no other color, for you shall dress
according to my will." In medieval times a woman's status (as a man's) could
be distinguished by clothing. Cloistered virgins, who by definition must
be unmarried women, were the only members of society who were permitted to
wear all white. The standard costume of medieval women consisted of primarily
dark shades, and in the case of noble women, was accented by bright jeweled
tones. During this time of poor sanitation, white clothing was impractical
for women of all classes. The starkness of white denotes a much stronger
connotation than simple impracticality in the work place; it also symbolizes
adherence to spiritual values. This association can
be documented in Matthew 26, in which all of the inhabitants of heaven are
clothed in white, indicating purity and goodness. The reader is provided
with evidence that Margery knew and understood the link between white and
holiness. In Chapter 6 Margery has a vision of the Virgin Mary as a child
in which she is clad in, "fair white clothing and white kerchiefs."
In medieval times it was customary
for a virgin to wear a ring given to her by the bishop at the time of her
consecration. This ring is akin to the ring a man gives his wife in the
ceremony of marriage. By accepting the ring, the virgin is pledging their
life and love solely to the service of her Lord. On more than one occasion,
Margery likens her relationship with God to that between man and wife. In
Chapter 15, the Bishop laid his hands on Margery solidifying her vow to
live a chaste life and accept the white mantle and ring of virginity. The
acceptance of Margery as a virgin by the church was essential for Margery’s
sense of self. In Chapter 21, Margery reveals that in her vision from the
Lord, he tells her, "For though the state of maidenhood be more perfect
and more holy than the state of widowhood, and the state of widowhood more
perfect than the state of wedlock, yet I love you, daughter, as much as any
maiden in the world." Therefore, although she did not fit the technical definition
of a virgin, she believed that God saw her as a maiden, and thus she had
a right to conduct herself as such.
Margery frequently returns to
the significance of white clothing throughout her tale. For a married woman
to clad herself in white was considered taboo by Margery’s society. Given
the magnitude of the statement her clothes would be making, Margery describes
herself as initially reluctant to embrace her calling. In Chapter 15 Margery
replies to her vision, "Ah, dear Lord, if I go around dressed differently
from how other chaste women dress, I fear people will slander me. They will
say I am a hypocrite and ridicule me." We see in later chapters that Margery
explains that her prediction of society's reaction was accurate. Much like
the adverse reactions she encountered in Chapter 2 by dressing above her
station in society, many viewed her wearing of white as form of false advertisement.
In Chapter 44, Margery admits that, "she suffered pain and abuse for wearing
her white clothes." However, since Margery views suffering in the name of
the Lord as virtuous, she is eager to emphasize the slander she must endure
due to her appearance. She is able to equate the persecution she endures
as a result of her clothing to the persecution Jesus and his apostles endured
due to preaching their beliefs.
References:
Atkinson, Clarissa W. Mystic
and Pilgrim: The Book and the World of Margery Kempe. Ithaca:
Cornell University Press. 1983.
back to the top
|