Anthropology 399-01
Gender and Globalization in Asia
Fall 2004

Study Guide Questions for Readings
Week 3: September 15

Read: Foucault, Discipline and Punish, pp. 3-31, 135-228

Foucault is difficult reading. Through his distinctive prose and vocabulary, Foucault creates a discursive world possessing many of the same properties of the "real" world he attempts to describe. In preparation for our class discussion, you should focus on the terms Foucault uses and how they relate to each other in his arguments about discipline and power. Then think about the ways you might challenge or revise his arguments.

We'll begin our class discussion on Wednesday by generating questions about Foucault, so come to class prepared with a list of things which you find confusing, interesting, or problematic.

1. What does Foucault mean by "power"? How does it relate to "knowledge," and how does knowledge operate?

2. How does Foucault describe and interpret a historical change in forms of punishment? Why are changing forms of punishment and discipline significant? Do you find his argument convincing?

3. What does Foucault mean by "discipline"? How does discipline relate to knowledge, bodies, and power?

4. Who exercises power in Foucault's argument? Why do forms of power change? Is resistance possible?

5. How might Foucault's discussion help us to understand the relationship between gender, globalization, and culture?

 

Question for Response Paper #2: Place, Bodies, and Discipline

Foucault's work describes the small and often unrecognized ways in which power shapes our ways of thinking by controlling our bodies. By "discipline," he refers to a mode of knowledge which employs techniques to control and regulate bodily movements. Such techniques are most obviously present in such institutions as mental hospitals, schools, military camps, prisons, and factories.

This assignment asks you to explore the significance of techniques of bodily control by considering the way a specific setting shapes the movements of the people within it. What relations of power do you think are involved? How do they differ from those described by Foucault, and how do you evaluate his arguments as a result of your findings?

HINTS: There are many possible settings: a workplace, a store, a school, a dining hall, a community center, a government office, a gymnasium, or a library. As a first step, you should diagram or describe in detail the physical structures of your chosen location: doors, windows, counters, walls, partitions, lights, tables, etc. Then observe how people move through the space. Are there spaces that are off-limits to some? Why? How does the space imply a way of differentiating between and organizing people? How is access to the space obtained (not just physically, but in terms of privileges, membership in a community, etc.) How are the activities which occur within that space directed? Are individuals working together collectively, in smaller groups, or alone? What are they doing, what kinds of motions are involved, and how do these seem shaped by the space or by the individuals who seem to manage the space? Are there individuals or groups who seem to be doing something different from what the space or its creators intend? Your paper should include a diagram of the space.

For tips about crafting response papers, click here.

 

Gender & Globalization Homepage | syllabus | study guide questions/response paper topics | research proposal | Leshkowich Homepage

HOLY CROSS

Home Page

Departments & Services

Sociology and Anthropology

 

For more information, contact:  aleshkow@holycross.edu