Here is a description of the Hawk and
Dove:
HAWK: very aggressive, always fights for some resource.
- Fights between hawks are brutal affairs with the loser being
the one who first sustains injury. The winner takes sole possession of
the resource.
- Although hawks that lose a contest are
injured, the mathematics of the game requires that they not die and in
fact are fully mended before their next expected contest
- For simplicity, we will assume that all hawks are equal in fighting
ability; that is, each hawk has a 50% chance of winning a hawk -
hawk conflict. Another way of saying this is that Hawk vs. Hawk
contests are symmetrical.
DOVE: never fights for a resource -- it displays in
any conflict and if it is attacked it immediately withdraws before it
gets injured.
- Thus, in any conflict situation, dove
will always lose the resource to a hawk, but it never gets hurt (never
sustains a decrease in fitness) when confronting a hawk and therefore
the interactions are neutral with respect to the dove's fitness.
- A corollary to this rule is that doves do not display for very long
against hawks. After starting their displays, they immediately recognize
that their opponent is a hawk and they withdraw without paying a meaningful
display cost. (press here to review the concept of display costs)
- On the other hand, if a dove meets a dove there will be a period
of displaying with some cost (time, energy for display) but no injury.
We assume that all doves are equally good at displaying and and
they adapt a strategy of waiting for a random time period (see "War of Attrition Game")
therefore when two doves face off, each has a 50% chance of winning.
- Notice that both doves will pay essentially the same display cost in
any contest. The winner is the individual willing to pay more. However,
note that the winner quits displaying essentially at the same time as the
loser withdraws (see war of
attrition game)
Equation #1:
Eq. 1. Payoff(to Strat., when vs. a Strat.) =
[(chance of win) * (resource value - cost of win)] + [(chance of loss) * cost of loss] |
Action
|
Benefit or Cost (arbitrary units)
|
Gain Resource |
+ 50 |
Lose Resource |
0 |
Injury to Self |
- 100 |
Cost of Display to Self |
- 10 |
Payoff to Hawk when vs. Hawk:
Eq. 2: E(H,H) = (0.5 * 50)
+ (0.5 * -100) = 25 - 50 = -25 |
Payoff to Hawk when vs. Dove:
Eq. 3: E(H,D) = 1.0 * 50
- 0 = +50 |
Payoff to Dove when vs. Hawk:
Eq. 4: E(D,H) = 0 * 50
+ 1.0 * 0 = 0 |
Payoff to Dove when vs. Dove:
Eq. 5: E(D,D) = (0.5) * (50
- 10) - (0.5) * (-10) = +15 |
Here is the payoff matrix for this particular version
of the Hawk vs. Dove game:
|
Opponent
|
|
Focal Strategy
|
Hawk
|
Dove
|
Hawk
|
-25 |
+50 |
Dove
|
0 |
+15 |
the fitness of Hawk, W(H), is:
Eq. 8: W(H) = h * E(H,H) + (1-h) * E(H,D) |
the fitness of Dove, W(D) is:
Eq. 9: W(D) = h * E(D,H) + (1-h) * E(D,D) |